Lumpkin (SDC)

SDC

Aggregated asylum decision statistics across all immigration judges recorded at the Lumpkin (SDC), based on public EOIR case data.

Lifetime grant rate

7.6%

All recorded asylum decisions

12-month grant rate

2.9%

Most recent 12 months of data

Lifetime decisions

4,534

Total grants and denials on record

Judges

Judges appearing in this court's data

Data through

2026-07

Latest month in the source data

Lifetime figures cover every recorded asylum decision. The 12-month figures cover only the most recent year of data — the same methodology over a shorter window, which is why the two views can show different percentages.

Court lifetime grant rate

7.6%

0%25%50%75%100%

All recorded asylum decisions

Monthly grant rate — trailing 12 months

Judges

Alberdi, Yon K.

20.0%

5 cases · 12-month grant rate: 20.0%

Arrington, Saundra D.

4.2%

287 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Baird, Michael P.

8.1%

74 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Barr, Philip A.

0.0%

6 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Bayse, Chad

0.0%

8 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Bell, Jennifer R.

33.3%

3 cases · 12-month grant rate: 33.3%

Brooks, Mark K.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Brown, Bianca, H

7.7%

389 cases · 12-month grant rate: 2.2%

Burke, Brian

0.0%

11 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Cassidy, William A.

0.0%

54 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Chait, Barry S.

20.6%

34 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Chapman, Kevin Jerome.

50.0%

2 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Cleveland, Chase Calder.

0.0%

3 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Coaxum, Ghunise L.

0.0%

8 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Corkery, Barbara

0.0%

2 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Criss, Scott D.

14.2%

401 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Crofts, James

0.0%

163 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

de Cardona, Lisa A.

11.9%

42 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Defillo, Irma Lopez

5.9%

17 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Donato, Robin

0.0%

4 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Doolittle, John R., II

0.0%

6 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Doughty, Blake

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Duncan, Randall W.

5.1%

373 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Farrar-Crockett, Emily

12.5%

8 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Fisher, Ryan

0.0%

4 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

French, Kathleen

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Fuller, Steven B.

4.2%

313 cases · 12-month grant rate: 7.2%

Gallow,Sheila E.

5.2%

58 cases · 12-month grant rate: 14.3%

Ghartey, Victoria L.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Gillies, John M.

0.0%

13 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Grim, James K.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Guidry, Monica Thompson

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Guilloty, Crimilda

7.7%

13 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Haer, Amy Fairchild

20.0%

5 cases · 12-month grant rate: 20.0%

Harness, Jerrica A.

5.9%

153 cases · 12-month grant rate: 3.7%

Harris, Rodger C.

0.0%

2 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Hawkes, Joshua

0.0%

4 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Hewitt, Andrew

1.7%

59 cases · 12-month grant rate: 2.0%

Houser, Wayne K., JR.

1.4%

70 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Isaak, Melissa I.

2.6%

38 cases · 12-month grant rate: 2.6%

Karden, Stuart F.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Kinnicutt, Daniel P.

33.3%

3 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Lampley-Fortson, Christa J.

0.0%

3 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Lassiter, Ashley

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Leonard, Joseph T.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Levinson, Eric L.

0.0%

2 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Lewandowski, Robert M.

33.3%

3 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Maldonado, Njeri B.

1.8%

165 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Mart, H. Kevin

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Martinez, Hugo R.

33.3%

3 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Martz, Nicholas A.

23.1%

13 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Masters, Bobbie C.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

May, Jennifer A.

100.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Mccullough, Charles M.

40.0%

5 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Murray, Winfield W.

25.0%

4 cases · 12-month grant rate: 25.0%

Nance, Jeffery R.

11.9%

160 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Napier, Wade Thomas

0.0%

15 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Nassar, Dania

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Onyewuchi, Morris I.

100.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Owen, Sirce E.

10.0%

10 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Owens, Alfredia

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Palmer, Brian T.

0.0%

21 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Pearson, Kyle A.

1.9%

53 cases · 12-month grant rate: 1.9%

Pelletier, J. Dan

4.2%

71 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Piateski, Jennifer E.

0.0%

18 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Pope, Jason L.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Redwood, Daniel J.

0.0%

2 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Rey Caldas, Carmen

33.0%

91 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Riner, Phoebe

1.6%

63 cases · 12-month grant rate: 1.6%

Rothschild, Jerome M., JR.

20.8%

159 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Schnitzer, Michael

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Smikle, Suzette

—