Otero (OTO)

OTO

Aggregated asylum decision statistics across all immigration judges recorded at the Otero (OTO), based on public EOIR case data.

Lifetime grant rate

17.4%

All recorded asylum decisions

12-month grant rate

7.1%

Most recent 12 months of data

Lifetime decisions

4,116

Total grants and denials on record

Judges

Judges appearing in this court's data

Data through

2026-07

Latest month in the source data

Lifetime figures cover every recorded asylum decision. The 12-month figures cover only the most recent year of data — the same methodology over a shorter window, which is why the two views can show different percentages.

Court lifetime grant rate

17.4%

0%25%50%75%100%

All recorded asylum decisions

Monthly grant rate — trailing 12 months

Judges

Abbott, William L.

8.3%

12 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Andrasko, Matthew

15.8%

19 cases · 12-month grant rate: 15.8%

Bain, Quynh Vu

20.0%

10 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Balasquide, Javier E.

40.0%

5 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Bass, Lori R.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Batko-Taylor, Abby Anna.

25.0%

4 cases · 12-month grant rate: 33.3%

Bonilla, Judith F.

0.0%

3 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Brown, Alison M.

20.0%

5 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Burman, Lawrence O.

23.1%

13 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Calcador, Kerri

0.0%

2 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Carbone, Nina M.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Costa, Philip J.

0.0%

3 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Crews, John G., II

0.0%

4 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Defoe, Craig A.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Deiss, Ila C.

50.0%

2 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Feder, Robin E.

33.3%

6 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Fernandez, Lorely Ramirez

17.6%

108 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Fluke, Randall L.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

French, Kathleen

1.5%

273 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Gagnon, Paul M.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Gallegos, Daniel J.

12.5%

8 cases · 12-month grant rate: 12.5%

Gardzelewski, Ivan E.

31.8%

44 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Garten, Danielle H.

0.0%

29 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Girvin, Ralph E.

4.8%

439 cases · 12-month grant rate: 3.4%

Gonzalez, Guadalupe R.

0.0%

10 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Guidry, Monica Thompson

90.0%

10 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Harlow, Craig A.

50.0%

2 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Hart, Brandon L.

20.0%

15 cases · 12-month grant rate: 27.3%

Herbert, Nathan L.

0.0%

3 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Hladylowycz, Roxanne C.

42.9%

7 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Ho, Anna

0.0%

8 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Holguin, Enrique A.

0.0%

2 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Honeyman, Charles M.

50.0%

4 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Hough, Robert S.

0.0%

6 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Ipema, Henry P.

33.3%

6 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Jiron, Graciela

0.0%

12 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Kane, Alison R.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Kaufman, Matthew W.

50.0%

2 cases · 12-month grant rate: 50.0%

Keenan, Sean H.

50.0%

2 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Kuipers, Benjamin

0.0%

10 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Law, Philip S.

0.0%

3 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Livingston, Donn L.

40.0%

5 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Lopez-Enriquez, Maria

0.0%

2 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Mahtabfar, Sunita B.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Maingot, Anthony E.

0.0%

5 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Martinez, Hugo R.

5.6%

71 cases · 12-month grant rate: 7.1%

Martinez, Susanna

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Masters, Todd A.

100.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Maury, Carlos E.

16.7%

12 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

May, Jennifer A.

0.0%

2 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Meredith, Steven

3.4%

177 cases · 12-month grant rate: 3.4%

Miles, Jessica K.

22.1%

77 cases · 12-month grant rate: 100.0%

Miller, Jr. James J.

10.0%

10 cases · 12-month grant rate: 14.3%

Munoz, Lorraine J.

0.0%

8 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Myers, Kyle

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Nelson, Barbara A.

12.5%

8 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Nugent, James A.

0.0%

6 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

O'Hare, Donald C.

56.5%

23 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

O'Sullivan, Maureen

28.6%

7 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Ozmun, Richard R.

18.2%

11 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Palomino, Jacinto

9.4%

741 cases · 12-month grant rate: 12.6%

Parchert, Brett M.

16.7%

6 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Pelletier, J. Dan

25.0%

4 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Pleters, Michael S.

4.5%

89 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Polivka, James F.

0.0%

3 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Razo, Danny

9.1%

22 cases · 12-month grant rate: 9.1%

Renner, Renee L.

22.2%

9 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Riley, Kevin W.

0.0%

7 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Roepke, Thomas C.

0.0%

124 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Ruhle, Stephen M.

1.8%

170 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Shahan, Kenneth

—