Otay Mesa (OTM)
OTM
Aggregated asylum decision statistics across all immigration judges recorded at the Otay Mesa (OTM), based on public EOIR case data.
Lifetime grant rate
28.9%
All recorded asylum decisions
12-month grant rate
26.8%
Most recent 12 months of data
Lifetime decisions
2,559
Total grants and denials on record
Judges
40
Judges appearing in this court's data
Data through
2026-07
Latest month in the source data
Lifetime figures cover every recorded asylum decision. The 12-month figures cover only the most recent year of data — the same methodology over a shorter window, which is why the two views can show different percentages.
Court lifetime grant rate
28.9%All recorded asylum decisions
Monthly grant rate — trailing 12 months
Judges
Anderson, Amelia
18.4%76 cases · 12-month grant rate: 12.1%
Archuleta, Judy
0.0%1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Attia, Olga E.
17.6%136 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Bartolomei, Rico J.
40.0%25 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Begovich, Samantha
34.5%29 cases · 12-month grant rate: 28.6%
Burch, Valerie A.
41.6%197 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Cho, Yul-mi
0.0%1 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%
Coughlon, Robert E.
50.0%4 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Daugherty, Daniel J.
0.0%1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Depaolo, Zsa Zsa
27.2%114 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Devitto, James
25.0%8 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Dixon, Paula
36.0%111 cases · 12-month grant rate: 35.7%
Driscoll, John T.
36.5%63 cases · 12-month grant rate: 36.5%
Glaser-Allen, Colleen
50.0%2 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Gonzalez, Yvonne S.
16.7%6 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Grande, Guy G.
21.2%146 cases · 12-month grant rate: 20.2%
Halliday-Roberts, Catherine E.
23.3%249 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Heesch, Meghan E.
18.9%95 cases · 12-month grant rate: 19.4%
Ipema, Henry P.
40.0%5 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Kim, Peter A.
0.0%1 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%
Law, Philip S.
22.2%27 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Martin, Clay Nelson
0.0%1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Munoz, Jeffrey V.
0.0%1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Najjar, George R.
33.3%15 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Nelson, Julie L.
33.3%6 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Nishiyama, Drew T.
0.0%3 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%
O'Connor, Lee
0.0%9 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Obrien, Leah
13.9%79 cases · 12-month grant rate: 13.9%
Ortiz, Ferdinand J.
51.2%43 cases · 12-month grant rate: 51.2%
Partida, Ana
35.6%233 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Paul, Nancy J.
0.0%1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Penalosa, Jose L., JR.
3.8%26 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%
Perez-Guzman, Virginia
33.3%3 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Perry, Anne Kristina
100.0%1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Robinson JR., Eugene H.
36.6%314 cases · 12-month grant rate: 35.0%
Romig, Jeffrey L.
10.0%20 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Salinardi, Jayme
16.7%6 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Sameit, Mark
30.5%370 cases · 12-month grant rate: 27.5%
Sarkany, Sergio F.
50.0%2 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Scala, Theresa
0.0%1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Simpson, Scott
—— cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Virchis, Bridget
—— cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Weiss, Daniel H.
—— cases · 12-month grant rate: —
Zander, Stuart J.
—— cases · 12-month grant rate: —