Back to all courts

Harlingen (HLG)

HLG

Aggregated asylum decision statistics across all immigration judges recorded at the Harlingen (HLG), based on public EOIR case data.

Lifetime grant rate

28.4%

All recorded asylum decisions

12-month grant rate

2.5%

Most recent 12 months of data

Lifetime decisions

3,225

Total grants and denials on record

Judges

53

Judges appearing in this court's data

Data through

2026-07

Latest month in the source data

Lifetime figures cover every recorded asylum decision. The 12-month figures cover only the most recent year of data β€” the same methodology over a shorter window, which is why the two views can show different percentages.

Court lifetime grant rate

28.4%
0%25%50%75%100%

All recorded asylum decisions

Monthly grant rate β€” trailing 12 months

25-0825-0925-1025-1125-1226-0126-0226-0326-0426-0526-0626-070%25%50%75%100%

Judges

Abbott, William L.

42.1%

19 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Achtsam, Howard E.

25.8%

194 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Ayala, David

41.1%

399 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Bain, Quynh Vu

33.3%

3 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Bashore, Jacob D.

26.9%

26 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Brooks, Mark K.

30.4%

46 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Brown, Charlotte D.

5.0%

40 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Burkhart, Margaret D.

90.8%

195 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Carreras-Amadeo, Monique

0.0%

1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Castaneda, Julian

10.3%

175 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Chapa, Teofilo

0.0%

1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Cigarroa, Barbara Gonzalez

41.0%

39 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Clancy, Sean D.

23.3%

60 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Cordova, David J.

100.0%

2 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Costa, Philip J.

100.0%

1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Crews, John G., II

22.8%

114 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Crosland, David W.

100.0%

1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Defillo, Irma Lopez

0.0%

4 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Dillow, Eric

0.0%

5 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Dornell, Lisa

0.0%

1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Dowell, J. Daniel

0.0%

1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Eller, Donald R., JR.

28.6%

14 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Ellison, Sarah M.

31.8%

66 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Fluke, Randall L.

50.0%

4 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Freeman, D'Anna H.

13.0%

131 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Galvao, Andrew

0.0%

31 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Garcia, Melissa Joy

41.9%

74 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Garcy, Annie S.

100.0%

1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Gilbert, Daniel B.

23.8%

42 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Gonzalez, Delia I.

14.1%

290 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 4.1%

Guidry, Monica Thompson

17.1%

105 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Hable, Paul A.

8.3%

48 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Hart, Brandon L.

32.6%

43 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Hladylowycz, Roxanne C.

100.0%

1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Hunsucker, Keith E.

0.0%

1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Jacobs, Richard C.

20.0%

5 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

John-Baptiste, Allan

50.0%

2 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Klein, Eliza

0.0%

1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Leeds, Frederic G.

0.0%

1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Leonard, Joseph T.

23.2%

155 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Martinez, Hugo R.

23.1%

13 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

May, Jennifer A.

17.0%

47 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Mcphaul, Glenn P.

0.0%

3 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Nettles, Marsha K.

0.0%

2 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Onyewuchi, Morris I.

1.6%

63 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Owens, Robert P.

37.5%

16 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Ozmun, Richard R.

0.0%

1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Peterson, William C.

32.9%

82 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Pimentel, Frank T.

6.8%

44 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Pineda, Christopher

9.0%

78 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 6.6%

Rodriguez, Adam

0.0%

54 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Sanders, Charles J.

0.0%

1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Schools, Shelly W.

20.3%

143 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Sydnor, Kelley N

β€”

β€” cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Thielemann, Christopher J.

β€”

β€” cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Tovar, Eleazar

β€”

β€” cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Uddin, Marium S.

β€”

β€” cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Videla, Gabriel C.

β€”

β€” cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Weisel, Robert D.

β€”

β€” cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Williams, Phillip T.

β€”

β€” cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Ybarra, Jesus Juan.

β€”

β€” cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β€”

Source: EOIR case data published by the Deportation Data Project. Figures count asylum grants and denials only.

Results may vary depending on the facts of each case.