Eloy (ELO)

ELO

Aggregated asylum decision statistics across all immigration judges recorded at the Eloy (ELO), based on public EOIR case data.

Lifetime grant rate

18.0%

All recorded asylum decisions

12-month grant rate

14.1%

Most recent 12 months of data

Lifetime decisions

5,200

Total grants and denials on record

Judges

Judges appearing in this court's data

Data through

2026-07

Latest month in the source data

Lifetime figures cover every recorded asylum decision. The 12-month figures cover only the most recent year of data — the same methodology over a shorter window, which is why the two views can show different percentages.

Court lifetime grant rate

18.0%

0%25%50%75%100%

All recorded asylum decisions

Monthly grant rate — trailing 12 months

Judges

Abbott, William L.

4.0%

101 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Alberdi, Yon K.

0.0%

7 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Bagley, Kenneth A.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Bales, Eric C.

100.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Bartlemay SR., Robert C.

13.6%

118 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Bartolomei, Rico J.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Bashore, Jacob D.

25.0%

4 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Burke, Brian

66.7%

3 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Butler, Jeremy J.

100.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: 100.0%

Castaneda, Julian

20.3%

79 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Christensen, Jesse B.

16.7%

6 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Cortes, John W.

20.0%

65 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Cottor, Elizabeth A

50.0%

2 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Coughlon, Robert E.

0.0%

4 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Davis, John W.

2.2%

404 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

De Angelis, Kathryn L.

27.1%

107 cases · 12-month grant rate: 23.8%

Devitto, James

3.5%

199 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Duvall, Bradly

0.0%

10 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Eller, Donald R., JR.

33.3%

6 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Ellison, Sarah M.

100.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Feldman, Irene C.

9.3%

313 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Fernandez, Ignacio P.

33.3%

3 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Fishkin, Andrew

9.4%

53 cases · 12-month grant rate: 9.4%

Freeman, D'Anna H.

32.4%

37 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Freerks, Lamonte S.

0.0%

3 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Gastley, Harry L.

0.0%

5 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Gaz, Jennifer I.

41.5%

448 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Grande, Guy G.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Griswold, Stephen S.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Habich, Paul M.

55.1%

345 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Hart, Brandon L.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Hong, Andrea

50.0%

2 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Hoogasian, Amy C.

33.3%

9 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Hsu, Lily C

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Imburgia, Joseph S.

100.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Ipema, Henry P.

0.0%

4 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Johnson, Jeremiah

43.5%

23 cases · 12-month grant rate: 43.5%

Kane, Alison R.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Karlen, Melissa Beth

38.5%

13 cases · 12-month grant rate: 11.1%

Keenan, Sean H.

1.0%

291 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Kessler, Elizabeth A.

0.0%

3 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Knuck, Richard H.

0.0%

9 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Kuipers, Benjamin

0.0%

22 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Leonard, Joseph T.

25.0%

12 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Lloyd, Michael

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Logan, Steven P.

3.6%

28 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Loprest, F. James, JR.

16.7%

6 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Mabry III, William

19.3%

238 cases · 12-month grant rate: 24.3%

Mart, H. Kevin

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Mathon, Lauren R.

44.4%

9 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Mccleskey, Loi L.

25.0%

4 cases · 12-month grant rate: 25.0%

McDonald, Kristofer R.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Medved, Paul N.

0.0%

8 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Montante Jr., Philip J.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Murad, Yvan E.

46.9%

32 cases · 12-month grant rate: 46.9%

Norregard, Aggie

3.7%

27 cases · 12-month grant rate: 3.7%

O'Leary, Thomas Michael

3.6%

169 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

ORECHWA, NICOLAS

8.8%

342 cases · 12-month grant rate: 6.1%

Penalosa, Jose L., JR.

62.0%

166 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Phelps, Richard A.

20.0%

466 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Piepmeier, Kristin

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Renner, Renee L.

0.0%

2 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Richards Jr., Marvin E.

0.0%

14 cases · 12-month grant rate: 0.0%

Romig, Jeffrey L.

0.0%

1 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Ruhle, Stephen M.

5.3%

19 cases · 12-month grant rate: —

Schnitzer, Michael

3.9%

230 cases · 12-month grant rate: 2.9%

Schulz, Karen W.

15.6%

45 cases · 12-month grant rate: 15.6%

Simons, Ian R.

—