Chicago (CHI)
CHI
Aggregated asylum decision statistics across all immigration judges recorded at the Chicago (CHI), based on public EOIR case data.
Lifetime grant rate
46.4%
All recorded asylum decisions
12-month grant rate
14.2%
Most recent 12 months of data
Lifetime decisions
27,128
Total grants and denials on record
Judges
102
Judges appearing in this court's data
Data through
2026-07
Latest month in the source data
Lifetime figures cover every recorded asylum decision. The 12-month figures cover only the most recent year of data β the same methodology over a shorter window, which is why the two views can show different percentages.
Court lifetime grant rate
46.4%All recorded asylum decisions
Monthly grant rate β trailing 12 months
Judges
Abraham, Shawn J.
0.0%95 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 0.0%
Ambrose, Dillon J.
0.0%7 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 0.0%
Arellano, Silvia R.
0.0%7 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Bain, Quynh Vu
0.0%1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Baird, Michael P.
0.0%2 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Baker, Glen R.
50.0%4 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Baldini-Potermin, Maria
65.2%66 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Bales, Eric C.
0.0%2 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Barilla, Jody
50.2%327 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Barrow, Sarjo
50.0%4 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Bashore, Jacob D.
100.0%5 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Beese, Matthew C.
7.1%198 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 7.2%
Bower, Glen L.
83.3%323 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Brahos, O. John
44.0%457 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Bratton, Scott
53.8%13 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Bukszpan, Joanna M.
0.0%2 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Burman, Lawrence O.
0.0%2 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Chapa, Teofilo
0.0%4 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Clemente, Jesus
0.0%2 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Cole, Samuel B.
48.9%577 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Conroy, Charles R.
0.0%1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Corrin, Melanie K.
37.5%16 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Criss, Scott D.
28.6%7 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Crites, Elizabeth
53.4%693 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 21.9%
Crosland, David W.
100.0%1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Cuevas, Carlos
59.8%1,200 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Curran, Brendan C.
26.6%658 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 15.1%
D'Angelo, Matthew J.
0.0%3 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Davis, John W.
0.0%3 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
De Angelis, Kathryn L.
64.9%666 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Defoe, Craig A.
29.9%1,487 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 10.4%
Der-Yeghiayan, Samuel
35.3%150 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Diaz, Irma
0.0%136 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 0.0%
Dierkes, Joseph
41.4%29 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Dillow, Eric
0.0%1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 0.0%
Dimarzio, Philip L.
2.3%173 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Eller, Donald R., JR.
6.6%350 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 4.0%
Ellison, Sarah M.
9.1%165 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Espinoza, Carla
68.6%220 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Feder, Robin E.
50.0%4 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Flesch, Kenneth
6.6%61 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 8.2%
Fluhr, Philip
53.3%182 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 100.0%
Freeman, D'Anna H.
2.5%242 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 2.5%
Fujimoto, James R.
49.2%616 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Garcy, Annie S.
0.0%1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Geisse, Loreto
66.7%3 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Giambastiani, Jennie L.
57.8%1,103 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Gordon-Uruakpa, Vivienne E.
0.0%2 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Gorland, Jennifer M.
100.0%8 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Gross, Kevin
0.0%3 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 0.0%
Guidry, Monica Thompson
0.0%2 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Hart, Brandon L.
0.0%9 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Hayward, Miriam
0.0%1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Hermus, Jason
0.0%1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 0.0%
Herndon, Megan B.
55.6%9 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Hladylowycz, Roxanne C.
50.0%4 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Hom, Sandy
0.0%4 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Horn, Michael C.
85.7%7 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Howard, Justin W.
13.3%15 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Ipema, Henry P.
0.0%1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Josephson, Kenneth
88.9%9 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Kassell, Joseph
0.0%1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 0.0%
Katsivalis, George P.
9.6%52 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Kessler, Elizabeth A.
0.0%1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Kim, Peter A.
6.7%30 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 8.0%
Klein, Eliza
50.3%292 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Klosowsky, Michael
29.3%1,166 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 10.2%
Lang, Elizabeth G.
56.3%439 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Leonard, Joseph T.
100.0%1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Luskin, Joshua D.
52.9%452 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 38.7%
Marshall, Jacob
0.0%3 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 0.0%
Mckenna, Patrick M.
38.7%1,492 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 7.9%
Mcnulty, Sheila
61.9%247 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Mencini, Ana
30.8%730 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 8.1%
Miller, Jane Chace.
0.0%1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 0.0%
Morley, Steven A.
0.0%1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Mullins, Ronald L.
0.0%1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Naseem, Samia
50.2%982 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 40.5%
Nelson, Kristi
52.3%132 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Owens, Robert P.
4.9%61 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Park, Jeannette Lim
71.4%7 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Paruch, David H.
0.0%2 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Patti, Sebastian T.
86.8%372 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 0.0%
Paul, Nancy J.
20.0%5 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Perez-Guzman, Virginia
58.5%352 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Perkins, Robbin
0.0%18 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 0.0%
Petrone, Anthony D., JR.
82.4%17 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Petty, Aaron R.
40.0%10 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Peyton, Jennifer I.
81.8%473 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Poarch, Jaime
1.7%58 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 0.0%
Poore, John A.
0.0%5 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 0.0%
Ramirez, Laura L.
25.0%8 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Reese, Agnelis L.
100.0%2 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Reynolds, Gina
66.6%820 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 38.7%
Riefkohl, Alberto J.
100.0%1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Rocco, Michael
0.0%1 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Rosche, Robin J.
56.1%741 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 0.0%
Salinardi, Jayme
57.1%7 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Salovaara, Kaarina
44.1%660 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 0.0%
Saltzman, Eva S.
62.9%790 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: 15.9%
Santen, Sean D.
50.0%2 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Santiago, Luisa
42.9%14 cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Smith, Renetta
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Stahl, Marc
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Stahl, Marc
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Status Docket
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Stogner, W. Wayne
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Sydnor, Kelley N
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Tijerina, Eric J.
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Treacy, Elizabeth
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Treacy, Elizabeth
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Treacy, Elizabeth
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Treacy, Elizabeth
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Tregerman, Gwendylan E.
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Uddin, Marium S.
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Venci, Michelle
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Venci, Michelle
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Venci, Michelle
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Venci, Michelle
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Venci, Michelle
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Verrillo, Philip
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Videla, Gabriel C.
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Vinikoor, Robert D.
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Vyas, Akash
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Vyas, Akash
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Vyas, Akash
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Vyas, Akash
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Vyas, Akash
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Yeargin, Robert
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Yokoyama, Lori
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Yokoyama, Lori
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Yokoyama, Lori
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Yokoyama, Lori
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Young, Elizabeth L.
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β
Zerbe, Craig M.
ββ cases Β· 12-month grant rate: β